Disclaimer: This is an independent review based on publicly available information. We may earn a commission if you purchase through our links at no extra cost to you. This does not affect our analysis.
You're dropping $60 a month on a picks service, and you need to know one thing: should you be hammering player props or riding locks? I've spent the last three years tracking both bet types across dozens of services, and here's what nobody tells you — the answer changes everything about your bankroll strategy.
Since my sophomore year blowing $1,800 following "guaranteed" locks that weren't guaranteed at all, I've tracked over 15,000 plays to figure out which strategy actually holds water. Let's break down props or locks from a profitability angle, not a hype angle.
Key Facts
- Player props typically offer more daily volume opportunities than traditional locks, especially during peak sports seasons.
- Lock picks usually carry higher unit sizes but lower play frequency compared to props strategies.
- The Locks By Tommy Monthly Player Props service combines both approaches at $59.99/month with 9,785 members.
- Successful props betting requires tracking multiple stat categories across different sports and platforms.
- Comparing strategies depends heavily on your bankroll size, risk tolerance, and time commitment to research.
- Services claiming +88 units in a month may be mixing both bet types without transparent categorization.
What Makes Player Props Different From Locks
Props are individual player performance bets — will Curry hit over 4.5 threes, will Mahomes throw over 1.5 touchdowns, that kind of thing. You're betting on stats, not outcomes.
Locks are the opposite mentality. You're backing a team or spread with higher confidence, usually at higher stakes. The best bet type depends on how you manage risk, but here's the reality: they're fundamentally different animals.
When I started tracking in 2020, I assumed locks would crush props because they felt more "serious." Wrong. Volume matters more than I thought. Props give you 15-20 plays a night during NBA season. Locks? Maybe 3-5 solid opportunities.
But volume doesn't mean profit. I've seen props bettors go 14-6 on a Tuesday and still lose money because of juice and unit sizing. That's the trap.
The Volume vs Confidence Trade-Off
Props let you stay in action constantly. For the action junkies reading this, that's either your dream or your bankruptcy plan. With locks, you're placing fewer bets at higher conviction.
From what I've tracked, props services average 12-18 plays per day. Lock services? Usually 2-4. That difference matters when you're paying monthly for picks — more plays feels like better value, but it isn't always.
At $59.99/month for a service like Locks By Tommy Monthly Player Props, you're getting both bet types, which actually makes sense for comparing strategies side-by-side in real time.
Where Player Props Win
Props shine when you've got deep market knowledge on specific players and matchups. If you're tracking injury reports, defensive rankings, and usage rates, you can find edges the books haven't fully priced in.
I've seen props strategies hit 58-62% win rates during stretches where the capper really knows their stuff. That's sustainable if — and this is huge — you're managing juice correctly and not over-betting.
The other advantage? Props don't get crushed by one bad play. You can go 7-3 on a night, bank profit, and move on. With locks, one bad beat on a 3-unit play can wipe out a week of grinding.
When Props Fall Apart
But here's where props get ugly. Variance is insane. A player catches the flu an hour before tip-off, and your over bet is cooked. Coach decides to rest starters in the fourth quarter, your points prop dies.
I tracked one service in 2024 that went 94-71 on props over two months — sounds great, right? They were down 4 units. Juice ate them alive, and their unit sizing was all over the place. That's the props trap: winning record, losing bankroll.
You also need serious time commitment. Comparing strategies, props demand you're checking lineups until game time. Miss one injury update, and you're throwing away money.
Where Locks Deliver (And Where They Don't)
Locks are about conviction. When you're backing a side at 3 units, you'd better have done the work. The best bet type for someone with a smaller bankroll is often locks, because you're making fewer decisions and limiting exposure.
From my tracking, solid lock services hit around 54-58% long-term. That doesn't sound sexy, but at proper unit sizing, it's profitable. The math works when you're selective.
But honestly, the pricing is steep when you're only getting 3-4 plays a day. You're paying the same monthly fee as a high-volume props service but getting a quarter of the action. For the volume bettor, that feels thin.
The Problem With Lock Services
Lock services love to claim ridiculous unit counts — "+88 units this month!" — without showing you the actual plays. I've tested 30+ services, and most are padding numbers with retrospective "lock" classifications.
When a service mixes locks and props without transparent categorization, you can't verify which bet type is actually driving profit. That's a red flag I watch for constantly.
And if you're following a lock service that's wrong on their big plays? Your bankroll gets torched fast. One bad 5-unit lock can erase two weeks of careful 1-unit wins. Risk management matters more than the win rate.
Which Strategy Fits Your Bankroll
If you've got $500-1,000 to work with, locks make more sense. Fewer decisions, clearer risk parameters, easier to track. You're not chasing 15 props a night and trying to remember which books gave you the best lines.
Props work better when you're sitting on $2,000+ and can weather variance. You need the cushion to go through a 4-11 stretch on props without panicking. Because those stretches happen.
For most people reading this, a hybrid approach is the move. Hit your high-confidence locks at 2-3 units, sprinkle in 0.5-1 unit props when you see value. That's what I'd run if I were starting fresh in 2026.
Services That Offer Both
Finding a service that delivers both locks and props in one subscription gives you flexibility. The Locks By Tommy Monthly Player Props setup includes daily VIP locks alongside player props picks, which lets you test both approaches without paying for two separate services.
At 9,785 members and a 4.6-star rating from 479 reviews, it's a mid-tier option that covers both bet types. Not the highest-rated service I've tracked, but the dual approach has merit for comparing strategies in real time.
I've written about similar comparisons in my Locks By Tommy vs TopTierBetz: I Compared Both Services Head-to-Head in 2026 breakdown, where you can see how different services structure locks versus props volume.
The Real Answer: It Depends on Execution
Here's what three years of tracking taught me: neither bet type is inherently more profitable. It's all execution.
Props can crush if you've got the time to research, the discipline to manage juice, and the bankroll to handle variance. Locks work when you're selective, patient, and not chasing losses with bad 5-unit revenge bets.
Most services claiming huge monthly unit gains are either mixing both bet types without transparency, cherry-picking results, or straight-up lying. I learned that the hard way in 2019 when I lost $1,800 following a service that deleted their losing picks.
If you're evaluating a picks service right now, ask them to separate props results from locks results. If they won't or can't, that tells you everything.
My Take on Player Props vs Locks in 2026
If you forced me to pick one strategy for the next 12 months, I'd lean toward props — but only if you're willing to put in the work. The volume creates more opportunities to find edges, especially with how fast betting markets are expanding in 2026.
But if you're working full-time and can't monitor lineup changes all day, locks are the better play. Quality over quantity matters when you don't have hours to research.
Honestly, with mid-tier services priced around $59.99/month now, I don't know how long that pricing holds — as these communities grow past 10,000 members, most start bumping to $79-99/month range. If you're going to test a dual approach, this is probably the window to do it.
The real question isn't props or locks. It's whether you're ready to track everything yourself, verify the results, and bail if the numbers don't hold up. That's the only way to know which bet type actually works for your bankroll.
Want to see both strategies in action? Check out my Best Player Props Service Whop 2026: I Tested Locks By Tommy's 9,785-Member Community review where I break down how the service structures both bet types and what you're actually getting for your money.
Affiliate Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. We only recommend products and services we believe provide genuine value.
